Unlike 225 mAb and 225 F(ab')(2), 225 Fab' fragment was a poor inhibitor of A431 cell proliferation. The weak antiproliferative capacity of 225 Fab' was not due to depletion of active fragment from cultures. When cells were exposed to exogenous EGF, monovalent 225 Fab' remaining in conditioned culture medium could act as well as the bivalent forms of mAb to block binding and tyrosine kinase activation by exogenous EGF. However unlike the bivalent forms, 225 Fab' fragment was unable to induce receptor dimerization and down-regulation, and it lacked the capacity to block autocrine activation of EGF receptors by endogenous ligand. These deficiencies were corrected by addition of rabbit anti-mouse IgG antibody, which also enabled 225 Fab' fragment to inhibit cell proliferation. We conclude that in A431 cells, inhibition of autocrine-stimulated proliferation by anti-EGF receptor mAbs requires antibody bivalency, which provides the capacity to produce EGF receptor dimerization accompanied by receptor down-regulation. These properties may explain the greater efficacy of bivalent mAb and F(ab')(2), compared with monovalent Fab' fragment, in inhibiting proliferation of a variety of malignant and nonmalignant cultured cell lines.